Originally appeared here: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/1503539444
The dialogues between Caroline and Simon don't seem believable. It seems to be rants between 10-12 year olds on the internet rather than exchanges between learned adults.
Abigail Barnette's "Bad Boy Good Man" is a preferable read. It has the same concept, yet the speaker actually sounds like an adult rather than an emotional preteen.